Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping Motive Possibly Identified as Someone She Knew After Officials Identify Her Suspect’s Name

Former police officer Charles Brewer, a frequent YouTube commentator on Nancy Guthrie’s case, recently posted a new video suggesting that Nancy may have known her alleged kidnapper.

In the May 25 video, titled “Nancy Guthrie Case: We May Have Been Looking At The Wrong Person,” Brewer challenged the widely held belief that money was the motive for the crime.

More from StyleCaster

For months, speculation swirled that Nancy’s disappearance was connected to her daughter, Savannah Guthrie, an Emmy-winning journalist and Today co-anchor. Many assumed that the assailant was after money, given Savannah’s notoriety.

However, as more time passes with few answers, that theory is losing traction. Now, some are wondering if the alleged abduction had less to do with Savannah’s fame and more to do with something—or someone—closer to Nancy herself.

“If this truly was a celebrity-targeted kidnapping connected directly to Savannah Guthrie, why has there been no meaningful ransom communication?” he asked. “Why leave over a million dollars untouched? Why create ransom-style messages that reportedly make little sense? Why no sustained negotiations or proof of life, no sophisticated extortion strategy?”

He continued, “Because if somebody kidnaps for money, money usually becomes the priority. But here, the behavior feels chaotic, disconnected, even emotionally driven, or possibly connected to something far more personal than the public originally believed.”

Brewer clarified that he wasn’t placing blame on Nancy’s family, but he was open to the notion that someone with a close connection to them could have been responsible for the tragic situation.

“Listen, if the public, including myself, was comfortable enough early on in discussing whether this crime was connected to Savannah Guthrie’s fame, her wealth, and public visibility, then it is equally reasonable to ask whether this case may somehow connect to someone else inside Nancy’s immediate world,” Brewer wondered.

He added, “Not necessarily family directly, but maybe somebody connected to them—like a friend, an associate, maybe a business relationship, or what about a debt? A dangerous person orbiting somewhere close to this family that nobody fully recognized at the time, because after more than 100 days, something still feels off. Something still feels untouched.”

Related: Savannah ‘Still Believes’ Nancy ‘Can Be Found’ as Her Mom’s Suspect’s Name Is Finally Identified

This comes after a report claiming that law enforcement may be close to identifying a suspect. In a recent interview with News 4 Tucson, retired Pima County Sheriff’s Department detective Robbie Mayer discussed how Nancy’s situation reminded him of a significant crime spree he worked on decades earlier. Back in the mid-1980s, Mayer played a major role in solving the “Prime Time Rapist” case, which involved a series of home invasions and sexual assaults committed by Brian Larriva in Tucson, Ariz.

He recalled the overwhelming challenge investigators faced with the case, sorting through “4,000 leads” before finally pinpointing Larriva, who died by suicide before he could be brought to justice. “One of the detectives had Larriva’s name as a lead,” Mayer said, “but he hadn’t gotten to it yet because he had so many leads in front of that.”

So, when it comes to Nancy’s case, Mayer is confident that “the suspect’s names are in those 50,000” tips authorities have received. For him, persistence is the key to cracking the case. “The question is if they can recognize it when they see it,” Mayer told the outlet. “Being in a case like this is like being in a field with rocks, and what you’re looking for is under one rock. You just have to keep turning.”

Best of StyleCaster

Sign up for Stylecaster’s Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.